I have read two of his three books in which, despite saying that he would never write such memoirs, constitutes. It examines certain flashpoints of american foreign policy from 1940 to 1970 through the lens of army air force lieutenant colonel, ford motors president, and secretary of defense robert mcnamaraone of the most hated. Jan 04, 2012 this collection is a timely reconsideration of the intersection between two of the dominant events of twentiethcentury american history, the upheaval wrought by the second world war and the social revolution brought about by the african american struggle for equality. This tape, together with a series of conversations between mcnamara and president johnson together depict mcnamara as being less. Learn more about the 1995 hanoi conference, when mcnamara met with vietnamese general vo nguyen giap, in argument without end. The fog of war brings together film transcripts, documents, dialogues, and essays to explore what the horrors and triumphs of the 20th century can. Mcnamara, and thus inevitably called mcnamaras 100,000, the project was a way to meet the manpower demands of an escalating war. The fog of war eleven lessons from the life of robert s. The story of america as seen through the eyes of the former. Errol morris and robert mcnamara interview 2003 duration. Typically, he notes that, only weeks after he was replaced, lbj also opted out. Mcnamara illustrated edition by blight, james isbn.
Robert mcnamara, errol morris return to berkeley to share. Robert mcnamara, by noam chomsky excerpted from class warfare. The conditions of mcnamaras departure from the pentagon were murky at the time and that murkiness speaks volumes about mcnamara. The fog of war by errol morris errol morris, robert s. Fog of war, mcnamara, war, kennedy, errol morris it is the story of america as seen through the eyes of the former secretary of defense, robert s. The film is presented in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 1. Robert mcnamara, by noam chomsky excerpted from class. Former defense secretary robert mcnamara, who died monday at age 93, offered an appraisal of the vietnam war in the 2003 documentary the fog of. The piece is a mix between historical footage and an interview with robert mcnamara by the director, errol morris. His opinions, insurance coverage insurance policies, and actions have led to a firestorm of debate, ignited most recently by errol morriss academy awardworthwhile film, the fog of wrestle. I have participated in two wars and know that war ends when it has rolled through cities and villages, everywhere sowing death and destruction.
One of the chilling scenes of the fog of war is mcnamaras farewell from the department of defense in early 1968. Three decades later, mcnamara wrote a book that was seen as a kind of apology for the disasters of vietnam. Qualifizierte bestellungen werden kostenlos geliefert. Mcnamara, morris and the fog of war filmmaker errol morris focuses on history through the eyes of a single man in the fog of war.
Robert strange mcnamara june 9, 1916 july 6, 2009 was an american business executive and the eighth united states secretary of defense, serving from 1961 to 1968 under presidents john f. In lesson one, mcnamara describes how empathizing with the enemy1 can lead to the swift end of a crisis, as well as to help to figure out the next moves. Mark danner in conversation with robert mcnamara and errol morris. According to mcnamara, what was the difference between the success of the cuban missile crisis and the failure of the war in vietnam. And he was a vocal critic of the bush administrations war in iraq. The use of lowiq troops in the vietnam war infinity publishing, 2015 arnold r.
Robert strange mcnamara, one of the most recognizable and controversial figures of the vietnam war, served as the secretary of defense under both john f. Mcnamara nov 15, 2019 mcnamara clearly agreed to do this interview as a way to take control of his own legacy. Mcnamara has 22 books on goodreads with 5534 ratings. Mcnamara s career spans some of americas defining eventsfrom the end of world war i, through the course of world war ii, and the unfolding of the cold war in cuba, vietnam, and around the world. In search of answers to the vietnam tragedy, published in 2000. Explaining the cuban missile crisis and director, belfer center for science and international. Mcnamara, the former secretary of defense under the kennedy and johnson administrations. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. When robert strange mcnamara ran the vietnam war as secretary of defense from 1961 to 1968, he let it be known that he had all the. The history channel has recently reaired errol morris acclaimed documentary the fog of war in which morris interviews former secretary of defense robert mcnamara and attempts to draw lessons. World bank and in many further activities, including several books.
Mcnamara, gets a deftly handled expanded treatment upon its release to dvd. Top 30 quotes of robert mcnamara famous quotes and. Lang use lessons from mcnamaras life to examine issues of war and peace in the 20th his opinions, policies, and actions have led to a firestorm of debate, ignited most recently by errol. The fog of war provides the background behind the academy awardwinning documentary by errol morris. For them and anyone else who needs a refresher course on america in vietnam, here is a short reading list from among the thousands of books written about the war. Dont answer the question they asked, the former secretary of. Aug 16, 2014 coincidentally, there is a 2003 documentary which receives its title from this concept. Arguably the best film yet by the awardwinning documentarian errol morris, the fog of war, a look at the life of former secretary of defense robert s. Mcnamara continued to wage his campaign to make amends for vietnam through the end of his life, most notably in errol morris oscarwinning 2003 documentary, the fog of war. We need a way to get out of vietnam, and this is a way of doing it. Millions died as the allies grinded down the axis war machine. Mcnamara 2003, directed by errol morris, is an american documentary film about the life and times of former u. In 1966, president lyndon johnson and defense secretary robert mcnamara were desperate to find additional troops for the vietnam war, but they feared that they would alienate middleclass voters if they drafted college boys or sent reservists and national guardsmen to vietnam.
The man is former secretary of defense robert mcnamara, whose. Berkeley near the end of fog of war, errol morriss documentary about robert mcnamaras examination of his role in the wars of the 20th century, mcnamara shares his philosophy for dealing with the press. First, although there have been several booklength biographies of robert s. Proportionality should be a guideline in war proportionality should be a guideline in war. In vietnam, we were unable to empathize with our enemy because we did not know them well enough. Lang use lessons from mcnamara s life to examine issues of war and peace in the 20th his opinions, policies, and actions have led to a firestorm of debate, ignited most recently by errol morriss academy awardwinning film, the fog of war. The use of lowiq troops in the vietnam war infinity publishing, 2015. Johnson, who appears notably less emotionally involved in the moment, has presented him with a medal.
It would be all too easy to assume that the war was a key stepping stone to the modern civil rights movement. Known as the architect of americas vietnam policy, mcnamara embodied the phrase the best and the brightest, the title of david halberstams classic account of the group of. In order to do good, you may have to engage in evil. Nov 28, 2017 the conditions of mcnamaras departure from the pentagon were murky at the time and that murkiness speaks volumes about mcnamara, johnson and the domestic politics of the vietnam war. If one is religious, edicts against killing are found in every sacred text.
Robert mcnamara and lessons from the fog of war bills. Oct 21, 2011 academy awardwinner for best documentary feature, the fog of war is the story of america as seen through the eyes of the former secretary of defense under president kennedy and president. Jan 01, 2005 in the companion book, editors james g. Mcnamara is one of modern americas most controversial figures. Coincidentally, there is a 2003 documentary which receives its title from this concept. Mcnamara 2003 pg documentary, biography, history, war. Morris interviews robert mcnamara, secretary of defense in the kennedy and johnson administrations, and finds a uniquely unsettling viewpoint on much of 20thcentury american history. This book should help teachers and students use errol morriss the fog of war as a launching pad for debating robert mcnamaras lessons about war and. Mcnamara is one of fashionable americas most controversial figures. When looking at the current libyan situation, these lessons can be similarly applied, and thus avoid any potentially costly mistakes like the ones made in vietnam.
Lang use lessons from mcnamaras life to examine issues of war and peace in the. Mcnamaras folly is heartbreaking to read, but it tells a story that most americans have never heard and that should be remembered far more widely than it is. The story of america as seen through the eyes of the former secretary of defense under president john f. Mcnamara urges us to remember that in order to do good, you may have to engage in evil. The film was directed by errol morris and features an original score by philip glass. In the fog of war, robert mcnamara breaks down 11 vital lessons he learned about war from the vietnam war. The vietnam center and sam johnson vietnam archive. Mcnamara is one of modern americas most controversial figu.
If people do not display wisdom, they will clash like blind moles and then mutual annihilation will commence. What robert mcnamara essentially describes in the fog of war, at least in the first five lessons, is the best way to achieve an end to war with minimal losses of both humans and resources. Robert mcnamaras eleven lessons in the fog of war and. He played a major role in escalating the united states involvement in the vietnam war. I have read two of his three books in which, despite saying that.
Killing 50% to 90% of the people of 67 japanese cities and then bombing them with two nuclear bombs is not proportional, in the minds of some people, to the objectives we were trying to achieve. Lang use lessons from mcnamaras life to examine issues of war and peace in the 20th century. Mark danner, robert mcnamara and errol morris in zellerbach hall, the university of california, berkeley. Jun 18, 2006 the fog of war 11 lessons from mcnamara. He was a war correspondent in vietnam and is the author of without honor. While allowing mcnamara to tell the story from his perspective, morris also. Robert strange mcnamara june 9, 1916 july 6, 2009 was an american business executive and the eighth united states secretary of defense, serving from 1961 to.
His opinions, policies, and actions have led to a firestorm of debate, ignited most recently by errol morriss academy awardwinning film, the fog of war. Mcnamara illustrating his observations of the nature of modern warfare. He is moved to the point of tears by the praise of president johnson. Opinion rethinking mcnamaras war the new york times. Timeless 21st century leadership and 21st century management lessons of character, courage and hubris. The fog of war is a film about the life and times of robert s. Berkeley, errol morris said his inspiration for the documentary derived from mcnamaras book. This book should help teachers and students use errol morriss the fog of war as a launching pad for debating robert mcnamaras lessons about war and peace. Kennedy administration of 19611963, robert mcnamara had important influence on the early escalation in.
You cant change human nature in mcnamaras mind war is a natural facet of the human experience, and he says, im not so naive or simplistic to believe that we can end all war. It is well known that world war ii gave rise to human rights rhetoric, discredited a racist regime abroad, and provided new opportunities for african americans to fight, work, and demand equality at home. Objectively, there is no greater evil than ending a human life. But fog of war shows that in reality the momentum for civil rights was not so. Dec 20, 2003 mcnamara, morris and the fog of war filmmaker errol morris focuses on history through the eyes of a single man in the fog of war. All world war 1 books showing 391 to 420 of 24,679 results most popular price, low to high price, high to low publication date, old to new publication date, new to old. Top 30 quotes of robert mcnamara famous quotes and sayings.
Robert mcnamara noam chomsky excerpted from class warfare, 1995. One of the most controversial and influential figures in world politics, he takes us on an. Mcnamara is a 2003 american documentary film about the life and times of former u. One of the most controversial and influential figures in world politics, he takes us on an insiders view of the seminal events of the 20th century. No matter what your opinion of mcnamara, the fog of war is a chastening experience. More fog of war official website synopsis watch clip storyboards academy awards acceptance speech fog of war glossary mcnamara gallery b29 cluster layout fog of war vs. The final product is the fog of war, created from 20 hours of interview material covering roles played by mcnamara in the firebombing of japan during the pacific war, the 1962 cuban missile crisis during the kennedy administration and the escalation phase of the vietnam war. Apr 12, 1995 comes now robert mcnamara with the announcement that he has in the fullness of time grasped realities that seemed readily apparent to millions of americans throughout the vietnam war. This book should help teachers and students use errol morriss the fog of war as a launching pad for debating robert mcnamara s lessons about war and peace. This tape, together with a series of conversations between mcnamara and president johnson together depict mcnamara as being less pro war than he is often charactarized as being.
1325 547 933 186 1221 1067 1027 26 255 536 656 63 157 513 860 1477 117 888 1385 126 334 1089 733 1507 1089 528 363 328 975 613 678 539 146 694 1252 485 764